Unveiling the Voices Within: Navigating Speaking Anxiety Among English Language Learners towards Honing their Learning Strategies

Shanti Polamuri

HOD, Assistant Professor

Department of English

Maharashtra College

Abstract:

Language is a powerful tool that allows us to communicate, connect, and express ourselves. As the world becomes increasingly interconnected, the ability to communicate effectively in different languages has become an essential skill. In response to this demand, language instruction methods have evolved, placing a significant emphasis on the development of oral communication skills. This shift has been driven by the recognition that speaking is not only a fundamental aspect of language acquisition but also one of the most challenging. However, amidst the efforts to cultivate these skills, an often-overlooked obstacle emerges—speaking anxiety. This article delves into the evolution of language instruction methods, the complexity of oral communication, the impact of speaking anxiety in second language (L2) environments. Furthermore, the identification process explains how these factors affect students’ ability to learn and perform in an instructional environment, given that L2 classrooms are often structured according to the formation of groups with different dynamics that may have a more significant effect or impact on learners’ speaking anxiety. 

Keywords: Language acquisition, speaking anxiety, instructional environment, language dynamics, difficulty of oral communication etc., 

Importance of language learning

The evolution of language instruction methods reflects a profound understanding of the importance of oral communication. Language is not merely a collection of words and grammar rules; it is a means to convey thoughts, emotions, and ideas. Recognizing this, language educators have shifted their focus from rote memorization and passive learning to active engagement through speaking. This transformation is fueled by the understanding that speaking is a vital skill that individuals must acquire to participate fully in a globalized world. However, the path to becoming an adept speaker is far from easy. 

Speaking involves a multitude of intricacies, including pronunciation, intonation, vocabulary selection, grammar usage, and fluency. The convergence of these elements requires practice and persistence. Despite its importance, speaking often poses a significant challenge for language learners. The intricate web of skills and knowledge required for effective communication can be overwhelming. Amidst this complexity, anxiety emerges as a formidable barrier.

Anxiety, particularly in L2 environments with limited opportunities for target language communication, can cripple the language acquisition process. Learners grappling with speaking anxiety may find themselves paralyzed by fear of making mistakes, being judged, or not being able to express themselves eloquently. As a result, they might avoid engaging in conversations or participating in class discussions, depriving themselves of the crucial practice necessary for improvement. Several studies focused on the significance of public speaking anxiety as a primary factor affecting academic achievement, sheds light on the intricate interplay between speaking English, speaking anxiety, and the L2 classroom setting. The emotional variables associated with speaking anxiety further complicate the landscape, as learners’ self-esteem, confidence, and motivation are profoundly affected. By examining these relationships, the study aims to provide evidence that anxiety is a leading cause of poor performance among language learners.

The evolution of language instruction methods reflects a shift towards prioritizing oral communication skills, recognizing their pivotal role in effective language acquisition. However, the complexity of speaking, coupled with the presence of speaking anxiety, poses a substantial challenge for learners, particularly in L2 environments. Several studies on speaking anxiety’s impact on language acquisition underscores its detrimental effects, focusing on public speaking anxiety’s role in academic achievement. Ultimately, understanding and addressing speaking anxiety could lead to more effective language instruction and improved outcomes for learners worldwide.

Learners possess an innate curiosity for the unfamiliar and a penchant for imitation, making it an optimal foundation for embarking on language acquisition. Observing their surroundings and tuning into the cadence of everyday life, children effortlessly assimilate language without conscious effort. This process occurs through a blend of aural and visual perception, nurturing their growth. Consequently, childhood serves as an opportune phase for language acquisition, characterized by an informal and almost subconscious learning experience. ELT has reached a point where the acquisition of language skills is of increasing importance. The level of acquisition is determined by the growth of communication skills, namely speaking. The deficiency emerges at this point because improving speaking skills at the school level received less emphasis. Students who lack accuracy and fluency lose confidence and motivation to utilise the language. Numerous variables influence the language-learning and -teaching process. The significant component is linked to the scenario of instructed language education. With this as the focal point, this study seeks to discover reasons for lousy performance, learners’ strategies to reduce nervousness, and expectations during speaking sessions.

Speaking Anxiety

Anxiety, a complex and uncomfortable emotional state, has long intrigued psychologists and researchers for its significant impact on human behavior and well-being. Initially defined by Freud as “something felt,” anxiety encompasses a distressing emotional condition characterized by feelings of tension, apprehension, nervousness, and worry, often accompanied by physiological responses triggered by the autonomic nervous system (Horwitz et al., 1986, p. 125). While anxiety is commonly linked to perceiving present or future threats (Barlow, 1988; Behnke and Beatty, 1981), it assumes a particularly powerful role in the context of second language acquisition, where it manifests as second language anxiety, profoundly affecting learners of English as a second language.

Oral communication in a second language is frequently perceived as an anxiety-inducing experience, resulting in negative outcomes for language learners. The act of speaking in a new language brings with it the potential for miscommunication, errors, and a sense of vulnerability. Consequently, the fear of these potential challenges triggers high levels of anxiety, particularly before and during speech engagements. This phenomenon aligns with the observation that speakers experience heightened levels of worry and anxiety in relation to their communication performance (Barlow, 1988). However, the study of this anxiety could serve as a catalyst for more effective communication practices, aiming to enhance individuals’ ability to convey their thoughts and ideas confidently and competently in front of an audience.

Within the realm of educational studies, anxiety has been examined as a relatively consistent personality trait, known as feature anxiety. Learners exhibiting this trait are prone to experiencing anxiety across various situations. In contrast, state anxiety is a transient emotional state triggered by specific circumstances, while situation-specific anxiety refers to a recurring trait associated with particular situations (Spielberger, Anton and Bedell, 1976). Notably, in the context of language learning, studies have revealed that language learning anxiety tends to be situation-dependent, indicating that it surfaces in specific scenarios (Gardener, 1991b; Horwitz, 2001). This propensity for situation-dependent anxiety is particularly pronounced in language learning environments, such as classrooms.

Anxiety as an intricate emotional state, holds considerable sway over human behavior and cognition. In the realm of language acquisition, second language anxiety significantly affects learners attempting to communicate in an unfamiliar language. This anxiety can stem from the fear of potential mistakes and miscommunications. However, by delving into the study of these anxieties, educators and researchers aim to empower individuals to navigate the challenges of speaking in a second language more effectively. Moreover, the distinction between feature anxiety, state anxiety, and situation-specific anxiety in educational settings underscores the complexity of anxiety’s manifestations and their implications for language learners. This intricate interplay of emotions and communication serves as a foundation for enhancing language instruction and promoting more effective communication education. As a student organises and prepares for an impending speaking activity or oral presentation in front of others, negative thoughts about the activity or session may exacerbate feelings of anticipatory anxiety linked with the assigned speaking task. This psychological phenomenon challenges teachers and instructors whose ultimate purpose is to educate and train students to be good communicators.

Awareness of Anxiety in the English Language Classroom

The pervasive influence of the English language has led to its recognition as a vital and essential component of modern life. Students, cognizant of its global reach and multifaceted benefits, attribute numerous virtues to their ability to speak English. From being perceived as “Universal” and “Global” to fostering a sense of “Prestige” and “Belonging,” English is regarded as more than just a language; it is a powerful tool that profoundly shapes their academic and personal journey.

For students, speaking English is synonymous with confidence. The ability to communicate effectively in this language empowers them to overcome linguistic barriers and engage confidently in various situations. It instills a sense of belonging, enabling them to connect with people across the world and be part of a larger, interconnected community. This interconnectedness not only facilitates personal growth but also serves as a conduit for international recognition. The universality of English enables individuals to expand their horizons, explore new avenues, and flourish on a global stage.

The impact of English extends beyond personal growth; it permeates professional spheres as well. Students are acutely aware that English proficiency is a prerequisite for internships, employment opportunities, and higher education in foreign countries. They understand that mastering English equips them with the tools needed for successful communication and exceptional engagement in diverse international environments. The language becomes an asset during presentations and interviews, allowing individuals to express themselves with eloquence and clarity, thus leaving a lasting impression.

Furthermore, the role of English in fostering effective communication is indispensable in various social contexts. Friendships are deepened through shared conversations, and the ability to comprehend diverse viewpoints enriches relationships. Mastery of English enables individuals to discern attitudes and emotions, thereby facilitating deeper understanding. This proficiency is not only valuable for interpersonal connections but also essential when venturing into unfamiliar territories. When traveling to distant locales, English assumes the role of a “Survival” language, enabling individuals to navigate foreign lands with ease and confidence. The practical implications of English extend to the global marketplace, where it emerges as a tool for professional competitiveness. English proficiency breaks down language barriers, allowing individuals to compete effectively in an international arena. It imparts a touch of sophistication to one’s profile, enhancing their history and increasing their appeal to prospective employers or collaborators. Moreover, it provides a pathway for articulating opinions, transcending cultural differences, and bridging gaps in a world increasingly characterized by diversity. The students recognize that English transcends mere language and assumes the stature of a transformative force in their lives. Its universal appeal, role in fostering confidence, facilitating connections, and enhancing professional prospects, paints a picture of an indispensable tool for personal and academic growth. The students’ profound understanding of English’s significance underscores its pivotal role in shaping their present and future endeavors, both on a personal and global scale.

The aspiration to master the English language resonates with countless individuals, making it a cherished dream for many. English speakers are often regarded as possessing a unique talent and innate gift. This sentiment is amplified by the fact that a substantial portion of pertinent literature and resources are available exclusively in English. For some, the allure of English stems from its ability to serve as a catalyst for achieving predetermined objectives, providing the means to turn aspirations into reality. Others are drawn to English by a genuine affection for the language, valuing the joy of speaking it, regardless of grammatical correctness—embracing it as an avenue for expression and enjoyment. Amidst these motivations, there lies a compelling rationale for learning languages beyond one’s mother tongue. This is particularly pronounced among learners who consider English a foundational subject within their academic journey. The necessity to study English is deeply ingrained, with its significance acknowledged as an essential component of their education. 

Many learners recognize that English is a pathway to frequent and eloquent communication, allowing them to convey their thoughts and ideas fluently. However, for a select few, English is more than just a subject of study—it is a dream that holds the key to their desired professions. Their professional and personal triumphs hinge upon their mastery of the English language. This realization propels them forward, as they understand that their command over English dictates their potential job prospects and the subsequent trajectory of their careers.

Interestingly, amidst the diverse motivations, a prevailing sentiment surfaces that learning English can be enjoyable and comparatively less arduous than other languages. This perception is rooted in the belief that English facilitates more effective communication and technological engagement. Beyond professional and academic motives, there are those who view English as a vehicle for personal fame, intellectual growth, and international recognition. The spectrum of reasons for learning English broadens further, encompassing a range of aspirations. Some are driven by an inherent passion for languages, seeking to immerse themselves in linguistic exploration. Others aspire to be known for their English proficiency, harnessing it as a distinguishing factor. The pursuit of higher education, a promising future, research publication, improved speech delivery, enhanced communication skills, knowledge acquisition, career advancement, and global travel all contribute to the allure of English.

However, despite these aspirations and motivations, learners universally acknowledge a shared challenge: anxiety when speaking English. This unease can significantly impact a learner’s adaptability to the target language and, consequently, their academic pursuits. The link between anxiety and oral performance is well-established, underscoring the need for effective strategies to address this hindrance. Interactive sessions are recommended as a remedy, providing learners with a platform to overcome their fears and gradually develop their speaking abilities. The desire to master the English language encompasses a diverse array of motivations, from personal passion to professional advancement. Learners recognize the transformative power of English, both as a means of effective communication and as a conduit to achieving their dreams. Yet, the presence of anxiety in speaking English highlights the complex interplay between emotional well-being and language acquisition. By addressing this anxiety and fostering supportive learning environments, educators can empower learners to fully embrace the opportunities presented by the English language.

Difficulties of Learners while using English

Learners of a second language (L2) encounter a diverse array of obstacles, often contingent upon the level of exposure they have had to the language. The challenges associated with L2 speech production are multifaceted, encompassing both physical and psychological elements. Among these elements, anxiety plays a significant role, stemming from a variety of valid factors. Issues such as extreme nervousness, lack of self-confidence, memory limitations, attention deficits, insufficient practice, deficient language command, incorrect communication, and inadequate opportunities for interaction all contribute to impeding the communication process. For some learners, cognitive processes can be a stumbling block, making it arduous to select the appropriate words (Woodrow 2006). The struggle to pinpoint the right terms, coupled with the desire to incorporate words from one’s mother tongue, further exacerbates this challenge. In instances of inadequate preparation or recall, confidence can waver, giving rise to heightened anxiety. The absence of prior experience in speaking in front of an audience, coupled with the fear of facing classmates, impedes effective communication. Moreover, concerns over task completion, constructing coherent sentences, and the distractions posed by fellow classmates can cause a breakdown in the communication process.

A pervasive fear is the uncertainty of what to express next during a speech or presentation. Learners grapple with the correct tone, pronunciation, and even forgetting the points they had intended to convey, leading to frustration and heightened apprehension. The struggle to conjure appropriate and unique words spontaneously is a common hurdle, resulting in instances where crucial information is missed during speech.

One of the most pronounced sources of anxiety arises when speaking in front of a group. Many individuals experience an overwhelming sense of terror in this context. The looming fear of stumbling, combined with concerns about potential memory lapses, adds to their anxiety. These anxieties can manifest physically, with shaky hands and legs betraying the inner turmoil. The obstacles faced by L2 learners in mastering oral communication are nuanced and varied, depending on their exposure and experience. The complex interplay of psychological and physical elements, compounded by anxiety arising from a range of valid factors, contributes to the challenges faced during speech production. From memory lapses to fear of facing an audience, these barriers can significantly impact a learner’s confidence and overall performance. Recognizing and addressing these challenges through supportive learning environments, interactive sessions, and strategies to manage anxiety are crucial steps toward empowering learners to navigate the intricate landscape of L2 communication with increased ease and effectiveness.

Strategy to Decrease Anxiety

In the face of an awareness of decreasing their anxiety, learners employ a range of techniques to mitigate their anxiety during speaking sessions. These strategies are designed to create a more comfortable environment, address anxiety-related concerns, and actively overcome the underlying causes of fear.

Guided by teachers’ overarching directions and supervision, learners have embraced tactics aimed at diminishing their stage fright. Techniques such as practicing speeches in front of a mirror to refine facial expressions are beneficial in combating stage fright. Teachers’ encouragement to ensure active participation from all students fosters a collective commitment to speaking, shifting the focus from apprehensive outcomes to the valuable experience itself. For instance, organizing English language games, honing reading skills, engaging with diverse environments, interacting with new individuals, seeking guidance from peers, recalling positive memories, and sharing these experiences before the class are all methods that hold the potential to alleviate anxiety. Additionally, learners advocate for participation in motivating tasks as a means to reduce anxiety, fostering a belief that tackling these tasks head-on enhances their confidence and lessens apprehension.

The importance of interactive sessions and brief presentations as anxiety-reduction strategies has been emphasized by learners. Adopting an “if others can, why can’t I?” mindset instills a positive attitude that bolsters their self-assurance. Expanding interactions to include individuals from different states cultivates a global perspective, promoting a more confident approach to English communication.

The notion that speaking in English leads to increased self-assuredness underscores the transformative power of language mastery. Nurturing amicable relationships with teachers and classmates has been highlighted as pivotal in creating an environment conducive to open expression and reduced anxiety. The freedom to voice opinions and views further nurtures self-assurance, while adopting a calm and composed approach to learning is deemed an effective antidote to anxiety. Thus, learners’ awareness of their weaknesses is accompanied by a proactive approach to addressing and mitigating their anxiety. The strategies they have adopted, guided by teacher input and personal experiences, underscore the significance of fostering a supportive and interactive learning environment. By embracing techniques that encourage engagement, global interactions, positive attitudes, and a calm mindset, learners not only diminish anxiety but also bolster their confidence, paving the way for effective language acquisition and dynamic communication.

Consideration, Perspectives, and Prospects

The expectations of students from their instructors in the context of language learning are indicative of a desire for interactive and engaging classes. Students look forward to classes that are not only informative but also enjoyable, achieved through interactive sessions that foster active participation. In the realm of L2 learning and acquisition, students value timely feedback, personalized interactions, private correction of errors, the emphasis on speaking and listening activities, a comfortable learning atmosphere, frequent opportunities for practice, a friendly demeanor from instructors, and the role of the teacher as a problem-solver.

A prominent sentiment generally shared by English language learners is their aversion to public reprimand or punishment. Learners place great importance on the establishment of a welcoming environment by instructors. They appreciate instructors who can identify errors and provide assistance in a supportive manner. Teachers are viewed as responsible for encouraging extensive reading to enhance vocabulary and reading speed, facilitating language growth through a comprehensive approach.

Feedback from students regarding speaking sessions emerges as overwhelmingly positive, providing both encouragement and room for the improvement of instructors. Some learners may possess the ability to speak but are hindered by their own shyness. The impact of these sessions is described as extraordinary, calming, revitalizing, joyful, and enlightening. Overcoming stage fright within these sessions grants learners a sense of accomplishment, fostering positive emotions. Importantly, the feedback loop established by teachers, who correct and offer assistance, is noted to have a profound impact on learners’ self-perception. The act of being guided and supported by teachers instills a sense of mastery and confidence. This newfound confidence translates into enthusiastic and committed participation in various activities, showcasing the symbiotic relationship between positive teaching practices and student engagement.

The students’ expectations from language instructors reflect a desire for engaging, interactive, and supportive learning environments. The importance of personalized interactions, private error correction, and a focus on speaking and listening activities is evident. The avoidance of public reprimand and the creation of a comfortable atmosphere play crucial roles in facilitating effective learning. Positive feedback loops resulting from teachers’ corrective guidance empower learners with confidence, leading to enthusiastic engagement in various learning activities. Ultimately, the dynamic interaction between students and instructors is key to fostering a rich and productive language learning experience.

Conclusions

The prevailing necessity revolves around establishing an environment conducive to language learning and infusing the process with enjoyment via interactive sessions. Nevertheless, learners are proactively pursuing chances to enhance and showcase their speaking skills. Consequently, the onus predominantly rests on educators to transform English learning and speaking into an enjoyable journey. This entails tailoring activities that align with students’ needs and preferred learning approaches. Equally vital is cultivating a receptive mindset among learners, fostering a high level of enthusiasm and eagerness to accept, acquire, and master the language.

References

1. Barlow, D.H. (1988). Anxiety and its disorders: The nature and treatment of anxiety and panic. New York: Guilford.
2. Behnke, R.R., & Beatty, M.J. (1981). Comparison of anticipatory and performance anxiety in public speaking. Texas Speech Communication Journal, 6, 3-6.
3. Horwitz, E.K., Horwitz, B.M., & Cope, J (1986). Foreign language classroom anxiety. The Modern Language Journal, 70(2), 125-132. 
4. Horwitz, E.K., (2001). ‘Language Anxiety and Achievement’, Annual Review of Applied Linguistics 21: 112-26.
5. MacIntyre, P.D., R.C. Gardner., (1991b). ‘Methods and Results in the Study of Anxiety and Language Learning: A Review of the Literature, Language Learning 41:513-34.
6. Woodrow, Lindy., (2006). Anxiety and Speaking English as a Second Language, RELC Journal, 37, pp. 308-323.
7. Spielberger, C.D. (1966). Anxiety and behaviour. Academic Press.
8. Spielberger, C., W, Anton and J. Bedell (1976). ‘The Nature and Treatment of Test Anxiety. In M. Zuckerman and C. Spielberger, Emotions and Anxiety: New Concepts, Methods and Applications (Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum) 317-44.
9. Tercan, Gulsah., Dikilitas, Kenan., (2015). EFL students’ speaking anxiety: a case from tertiary level students, International Association of Research in Foreign Language education and Applied Linguistics ELT Research Journal. 2015, 4(1), 16-27 ISSN: 2146-9814.