By Kavita Dehalwar

Interviews are a central method of gathering qualitative data across disciplines, particularly in research, psychology, human resources, and customer service. Broadly, interviews can be classified into structured, semi-structured, and unstructured types. Each of these types serves a unique purpose and provides varying levels of flexibility and control over the data-gathering process. Here’s a detailed breakdown of each type:

1. Structured Interviews

Definition: Structured interviews are a standardized approach to interviewing where the interviewer follows a predetermined set of questions, asked in a specific order, with little to no deviation. The questions are often closed-ended, focusing on eliciting specific information from respondents.

Key Characteristics:

• Standardization: All interviewees are asked identical questions in the same sequence, ensuring consistency across interviews.
• Fixed Response Options: Often, structured interviews include closed-ended questions, allowing for objective comparison across responses.
• Limited Flexibility: The interviewer does not deviate from the script, leaving little room for follow-up or probing questions.
• Objective Scoring: In many cases, responses can be scored or rated, making it possible to quantify results.

Advantages:

• Reliability and Consistency: Because the structure is rigid, responses are easier to compare and analyze statistically, which improves the reliability of findings.
• Efficiency: Structured interviews tend to be shorter and more focused, making them ideal when time or resources are limited.
• Reduced Interviewer Bias: With a fixed set of questions, the likelihood of interviewer bias affecting responses is minimized.

Disadvantages:

• Limited Depth: Structured interviews lack flexibility, making it difficult to explore topics beyond the predetermined questions, which may limit the depth of information gathered.
• Inflexible Responses: Respondents may find it challenging to fully express their thoughts within the confines of closed-ended questions.

Applications:

• Hiring and Recruitment: Structured interviews are common in initial screening processes, where specific job-related competencies are evaluated.
• Surveys: Many survey-based interviews (e.g., census interviews) use structured formats for consistency and reliability.
• Research Studies: Structured interviews are often used in studies that require quantifiable data, such as psychological assessments or standardized tests.

---

2. Semi-Structured Interviews

Definition: Semi-structured interviews use a blend of predetermined questions and the flexibility to explore topics as they arise. Interviewers start with a set of key questions but can deviate to probe for additional information based on the respondent’s answers.

Key Characteristics:

• Guided Structure: A framework of core questions is provided, but the interviewer can ask follow-up questions, depending on responses.
• Flexibility: Unlike structured interviews, semi-structured interviews allow for spontaneous questions that provide richer data.
• Open-Ended Questions: Questions are generally open-ended, allowing interviewees to elaborate and provide nuanced responses.

Advantages:

• Balance of Consistency and Flexibility: Semi-structured interviews combine the structure needed to guide the conversation with the flexibility to explore unplanned topics in depth.
• In-Depth Data Collection: The open-ended nature allows for deeper insights, as participants can share more detailed, personal information.
• Improved Rapport: Semi-structured interviews foster a more conversational style, which can make interviewees feel more comfortable and open.

Disadvantages:

• Time-Consuming: Semi-structured interviews require more time to conduct and analyze, as responses are often longer and more complex.
• Interviewer Skill Dependency: The effectiveness of semi-structured interviews depends on the interviewer’s ability to ask relevant follow-up questions and guide the conversation.
• Subjective Interpretation: Because responses are open-ended, interpretation can be subjective, requiring careful analysis to avoid biases.

Applications:

• Qualitative Research: Semi-structured interviews are frequently used in fields like sociology, anthropology, and psychology to gather rich qualitative data.
• Customer Feedback: Organizations often use semi-structured interviews to understand customer needs and preferences in detail.
• Performance Appraisals: Semi-structured interviews are common in performance evaluations, where feedback can be explored in depth through a blend of preset and flexible questions.

---

3. Unstructured Interviews

Definition: Unstructured interviews are the most flexible type, with no predetermined set of questions. Instead, the interviewer and interviewee engage in an open, free-flowing conversation where topics can evolve based on the participant’s responses.

Key Characteristics:

• Complete Flexibility: The interviewer can ask any question based on the conversation flow, without being constrained by a script or structure.
• Participant-Led: Often, the participant’s responses guide the direction of the interview, allowing for exploration of topics that might not have been initially considered.
• High Depth and Detail: Unstructured interviews often yield highly detailed and personal insights, as interviewees are free to discuss topics in-depth.

Advantages:

• Depth and Richness of Data: Because there is no structure, interviewees can express themselves freely, leading to unique, valuable insights.
• Adaptability: Unstructured interviews are ideal for exploring complex, sensitive topics where a structured approach might limit expression.
• Rapport Building: The conversational nature often helps interviewees feel at ease, fostering a sense of trust that can yield honest responses.

Disadvantages:

• Difficulty in Analysis: Data from unstructured interviews can be challenging to organize and analyze, as responses vary widely and lack uniformity.
• Interviewer Skill Requirement: Successful unstructured interviews require high interviewer skills, including active listening, adaptability, and the ability to ask relevant probing questions.
• Time-Consuming: Without a predetermined structure, unstructured interviews can be lengthy, both in conducting and analyzing responses.

Applications:

• Exploratory Research: Often used in exploratory studies where the objective is to uncover new insights or hypotheses rather than test existing ones.
• Therapy and Counseling: Therapists often use an unstructured approach, allowing clients to direct conversations based on what they feel comfortable sharing.
• Investigative Journalism: Journalists frequently use unstructured interviews to gather in-depth, personal stories that may reveal new angles to a story.

---

Summary Table

Interview Type	Structure	Flexibility	Data Depth	Common Applications
Structured	High	Low	Low	Surveys, hiring, standardized research
Semi-Structured	Moderate	Moderate	Moderate	Qualitative research, feedback, appraisals
Unstructured	None	High	High	Therapy, exploratory research, journalism

In choosing an interview type, one should consider the purpose of the interview, the desired depth of information, available time, and the skills of the interviewer. Structured interviews provide consistency, while unstructured ones allow for richer insights, and semi-structured interviews offer a balance between the two.

References

Adeoye‐Olatunde, O. A., & Olenik, N. L. (2021). Research and scholarly methods: Semi‐structured interviews. Journal of the american college of clinical pharmacy, 4(10), 1358-1367.

Brinkmann, S. (2014). Unstructured and semi-structured interviewing. The Oxford handbook of qualitative research, 2, 277-299.

Dehalwar, K., & Sharma, S. N. (2023). Fundamentals of Research Writing and Uses of Research Methodologies. Edupedia Publications Pvt Ltd.

Dehalwar, K., & Sharma, S. N. (2024). Exploring the Distinctions between Quantitative and Qualitative Research Methods. Think India Journal, 27(1), 7-15.

Dehalwar, K. (Ed.). (2024). Basics of Research Methodology-Writing and Publication. EduPedia Publications Pvt Ltd.

Kumar, G., Vyas, S., Sharma, S. N., & Dehalwar, K. (2024). Challenges of Environmental Health in Waste Management for Peri-urban Areas. In Solid Waste Management: Advances and Trends to Tackle the SDGs (pp. 149-168). Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland.

Low, J. (2019). Unstructured and semi–structured interviews in Health Research. Researching Health: Qualitative, Quantitative and Mixed methods. London: Sage publications, 123-41.

Miller, P. R., Dasher, R., Collins, R., Griffiths, P., & Brown, F. (2001). Inpatient diagnostic assessments: 1. Accuracy of structured vs. unstructured interviews. Psychiatry research, 105(3), 255-264.

Segal, D. L., Coolidge, F. L., O’Riley, A., & Heinz, B. A. (2006). Structured and semistructured interviews. In Clinician’s handbook of adult behavioral assessment (pp. 121-144). Academic Press.

Sharma, S. N., Lodhi, A. S., Dehalwar, K., & Jaiswal, A. (2024, June). Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) of Recycled & Secondary Materials in the Construction of Roads. In IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science (Vol. 1326, No. 1, p. 012102). IOP Publishing.